Volume 14
Melissa Turner: The Cosplay Cam Girl

Volume 14 · Chapter 3

The Cosplay Cam Girl

Melissa Turner

Victim: Matt Tressler

Riverview, Hillsborough County, Florida 4 photos

Case at a glance

When
October 18, 2019
Where
Riverview, Hillsborough County, Florida
Perpetrator
Melissa Rose Turner
Victim
Matt Tressler
Outcome
Convicted of second-degree murder in February 2022 and sentenced to 20½ years in prison

The case

Melissa Turner lost about 90 pounds between 2011 and 2013 and turned the change into a living, building an online following as a cosplay model and cam performer. She shared a house in Riverview, a suburb of Tampa, Florida, with her fiancé, Matthew Trussler, who had moved to Florida for a fresh start after struggling with substance abuse.

On October 18, 2019, after a night of heavy drinking, Trussler died from a deep knife wound to his upper arm. Hours later Turner called 911 to say he was unresponsive and told investigators she had found him on the back patio. She later said she had stabbed him to escape his attack. Security cameras contradicted her. The couple’s indoor ADT camera showed a calm Trussler and a furious Turner rushing around, her right hand bloody, and a camera on a neighbor’s garage recorded her screaming at him to get up and to go die.

Prosecutors also stressed the roughly four hours that passed before she called for help. Turner turned down a 25-year plea offer and went to trial. On February 18, 2022, a Hillsborough County jury found her guilty of second-degree murder, and in March 2022 she was sentenced to 20½ years in prison. The judge said neither the jury nor the court believed her account of self-defense.

From the book

Read the full story

This case is told in full in True Crime Case Histories, Volume 14 by Jason Neal.

Get Volume 14 on Amazon

Case photographs

4 photos
Matt Tressler & Melissa Turner
Matt Tressler & Melissa Turner
Matt Tressler & Melissa Turner
Matt Tressler & Melissa Turner
Matt Tressler & Melissa Turner
Matt Tressler & Melissa Turner
Matt Tressler & Melissa Turner
Matt Tressler & Melissa Turner

Where it happened

Riverview, FL
Riverview, where Matthew Trussler was killed · Open in Google Maps

Why this case

“I rarely build a chapter around audio, but this one depends on it. Turner’s version of that night was detailed and confident, and a camera on a neighbor’s garage told a different story. Matthew came to Florida to start over. That recording is the closest thing we have to his side of it.”

Jason Neal, author of True Crime Case Histories

More from Volume 14

12 chapters
Byron Smith: The Castle Doctrine

The Castle Doctrine

Chapter 1 · Byron Smith

Byron Smith shot teenagers Nick Brady and Haile Kifer in the basement of his Little Falls, Minnesota, home on Thanksgiving Day 2012. Case photos.

Timothy Wilson Spencer: The South Side Strangler

The South Side Strangler

Chapter 2 · Timothy Wilson Spencer

Timothy Wilson Spencer, the Southside Strangler, murdered four women in Richmond, Chesterfield County and Arlington, Virginia, in 1987. Case photos.

Jesse Kempson: Room 308

Room 308

Chapter 4 · Jesse Kempson

Jesse Kempson murdered British backpacker Grace Millane after a Tinder date in Auckland, New Zealand, in December 2018. Photos from the case.

Joseph Zieler: The Cape Coral Monster

The Cape Coral Monster

Chapter 5 · Joseph Zieler

Joseph Zieler killed Lisa Story and 11-year-old Robin Cornell in Cape Coral, Florida, in 1990 and was identified by DNA in 2016. Case photos.

Daniel Wozniak: A Bad Actor

A Bad Actor

Chapter 6 · Daniel Wozniak

Daniel Wozniak murdered Sam Herr and Julie Kibuishi in Los Alamitos and Costa Mesa, California, in May 2010 to pay for his wedding. Case photos.

Pam Hupp: The Frame-up

The Frame-up

Chapter 7 · Pam Hupp

Pam Hupp, Betsy Faria’s 2011 stabbing in Troy, Missouri, Russ Faria’s wrongful conviction and the 2016 killing of Louis Gumpenberger. Case photos.

Robert Anthony Buell: The City Planner

The City Planner

Chapter 8 · Robert Anthony Buell

Robert Anthony Buell, the Akron city worker who killed Krista Harrison in 1982 and Tina Harmon in 1981 in northern Ohio. Photos from the Buell case.

Charles Rathbun: Death of a Cheerleader

Death of a Cheerleader

Chapter 9 · Charles Rathbun

Charles Rathbun, the Hollywood photographer who killed former Raiderette Linda Sobek in the Angeles National Forest in 1995. Case photos.

Joshua Webb: Mother’s Day

Mother’s Day

Chapter 10 · Joshua Webb

Joshua Webb, who killed his mother Tina Webb in Colton, Oregon, on Mother’s Day 2017, then attacked a worker in an Estacada store. Case photos.

Douglas Garland: Collateral Damage

Collateral Damage

Chapter 11 · Douglas Garland

Douglas Garland and the 2014 murders of Alvin and Kathy Liknes and their grandson Nathan O’Brien in Calgary, Alberta. Photos from the Garland case.

Melanie McGuire: The Suitcase Killer

The Suitcase Killer

Chapter 12 · Melanie McGuire

Melanie McGuire, the New Jersey nurse who killed husband Bill McGuire in Woodbridge in 2004 and hid his remains in the Chesapeake Bay. Case photos.

About the author

Jason Neal writes the True Crime Case Histories series, which has covered hundreds of real cases from the United States and around the world since 2019. Each volume collects twelve cases, researched from court records, police reports and news coverage. jasonneal.com

Read it in Volume 14 next chapterJesse Kempson