Volume 17
Norman Porter: The Killer Poet

Volume 17 · Chapter 8

The Killer Poet

Norman Arthur Porter Jr

Victims: John “Jackie” Pigott · David S. Robinson

Saugus and Cambridge, Massachusetts; Chicago, Illinois 5 photos

Case at a glance

When
September 1960 and 1961; captured March 2005
Where
Saugus and Cambridge, Massachusetts; Chicago, Illinois
Perpetrator
Norman Arthur Porter Jr. (alias J.J. Jameson)
Victims
John “Jackie” Pigott, David S. Robinson
Outcome
Pleaded guilty to two second-degree murders and received consecutive life terms; escaped 1985, recaptured 2005, paroled in 2022, and died in December 2023

The case

Norman Porter was twenty on September 29, 1960, when he and an accomplice robbed the Robert Hall clothing store in Saugus, Massachusetts. Store clerk John “Jackie” Pigott was killed with a sawed-off shotgun, and the manager was wounded. In 1961, while awaiting trial in the Middlesex County jail in Cambridge, Porter helped plan an escape during which jail master David S. Robinson was shot dead. Porter pleaded guilty to second-degree murder for both deaths and received consecutive life sentences.

He spent the next twenty-five years in prison, where he wrote poetry. On December 21, 1985, he walked away from the Norfolk Pre-Release Center and vanished. He turned up in Chicago as J.J. Jameson, a bearded poet and activist who did handyman work at the Third Unitarian Church. In March 2005 a poetry website named him its Poet of the Month and posted his photo. Investigators matched fingerprints from a 1993 arrest to Porter, and officers took him into custody at the church on March 22, 2005.

Returned to Massachusetts, Porter received three more years for the escape. The parole board turned him down repeatedly, most recently in 2019. At a March 2022 hearing he apologized to both families, and on July 5, 2022, the board approved his release with a curfew and electronic monitoring. In failing health, he died on December 27, 2023, at age 83.

From the book

Read the full story

This case is told in full in True Crime Case Histories, Volume 17 by Jason Neal.

Get Volume 17 on Amazon

Case photographs

5 photos
Norman Porter / JJ Jameson
Norman Porter / JJ Jameson
Norman Porter / JJ Jameson
Norman Porter / JJ Jameson
Norman Porter / JJ Jameson
Norman Porter / JJ Jameson
Norman Porter / JJ Jameson
Norman Porter / JJ Jameson
Norman Porter / JJ Jameson
Norman Porter / JJ Jameson

Where it happened

Third Unitarian Church
The Chicago church where Norman Porter was arrested in 2005 · Open in Google Maps

Why this case

“Porter’s case raises a question without an easy answer: what does a man owe once he has built a decent-looking life on a lie? Chicago knew a gentle poet. The Pigott and Robinson families knew something else, and for twenty years they had no idea where he was.”

Jason Neal, author of True Crime Case Histories

More from Volume 17

12 chapters
Katherine Knight: The Butcher of Aberdeen

The Butcher of Aberdeen

Chapter 1 · Katherine Knight

Katherine Knight killed John Price in Aberdeen, NSW, in 2000 and was the first Australian woman jailed for life without parole. Case photos.

Suzanne Capper: Langworthy Road

Langworthy Road

Chapter 2 · Suzanne Capper

The 1992 torture and murder of 16-year-old Suzanne Capper in Moston, Manchester, and the four killers convicted of her murder in 1993. Case photos.

Brian Wells: The Pizza Bomber

The Pizza Bomber

Chapter 3 · Brian Wells

Pizza delivery driver Brian Wells died when a collar bomb exploded after a 2003 bank robbery in Erie, Pennsylvania. The case and photos.

Stanley Detweiler: The REDRUM Murder

The REDRUM Murder

Chapter 4 · Stanley Detweiler

The 1987 “REDRUM” killing of Stanley Detweiler in Reading, Pennsylvania, and the two men convicted, John Calvaresi and Michael Boettlin. Case photos.

John Strange: A Strange Case

A Strange Case

Chapter 5 · John Strange

Louisville teacher John Strange murdered his wife Kathleen in 1990 and tried to hide it with a fire at a vacant house in Kentucky. Case photos.

Stuart Knowlton: The Vanishing

The Vanishing

Chapter 6 · Stuart Knowlton

Stuart Knowlton abducted and murdered six-year-old Cassie Hansen from a St. Paul, Minnesota, church in November 1981. Photos from the case.

Donald Blom: The Night Shift

The Night Shift

Chapter 7 · Donald Blom

Donald Blom abducted 19-year-old clerk Katie Poirier from a Moose Lake, Minnesota, gas station in 1999, a crime caught on video. Case photos.

Dale Scheanette: The Bathtub Killer

The Bathtub Killer

Chapter 9 · Dale Scheanette

Dale Scheanette killed Christine Vu and Wendie Prescott at the Peartree Apartments in Arlington, Texas, in 1996. Photos from the bathtub killer case.

Rosalyn Hunt: Child of Chaos

Child of Chaos

Chapter 10 · Rosalyn Hunt

Paul Clarke and 15-year-old Lorraine Thorpe killed Rosalyn Hunt and Desmond Thorpe in Ipswich, England, in August 2009. Photos from the case.

Ken McElroy: He Needed Killing

He Needed Killing

Chapter 11 · Ken McElroy

Ken Rex McElroy, the bully of Skidmore, Missouri, was shot dead on Main Street in July 1981 before dozens of witnesses. No one was ever charged. Photos.

Christopher Foster: The Millionaire

The Millionaire

Chapter 12 · Christopher Foster

Christopher Foster shot his wife Jill and daughter Kirstie, then burned Osbaston House in Maesbrook, Shropshire, in August 2008. Photos from the case.

About the author

Jason Neal writes the True Crime Case Histories series, which has covered hundreds of real cases from the United States and around the world since 2019. Each volume collects twelve cases, researched from court records, police reports and news coverage. jasonneal.com

Read it in Volume 17 next chapterDale Scheanette