Volume 22
John Hummel: The Kennedale Murders

Volume 22 · Chapter 8

The Kennedale Murders

John Hummel

Victims: Joy Hummel · Clyde “Eddie” Bedford · Jodi Hummel

Kennedale, Texas, in Tarrant County 2 photos

Case at a glance

When
December 17, 2009
Where
Kennedale, Texas, in Tarrant County
Perpetrator
John William Hummel
Victims
Joy Hummel, Clyde “Eddie” Bedford, Jodi Hummel
Outcome
Convicted of capital murder in June 2011 and sentenced to death; executed by lethal injection on June 30, 2021

The case

John Hummel was a 34-year-old former Marine who worked overnight security at a hospital in Arlington, Texas, and lived in Kennedale, a small city southeast of Fort Worth. In October 2009 he began an affair with a convenience-store clerk. Not long after, he tried to kill his family with rat poison stirred into a spaghetti dinner. Joy threw the meal out because the meat had turned green.

On the night of December 17, 2009, Hummel stabbed his wife Joy, who was 34 and pregnant, dozens of times in her bed. She fought him hard enough to leave scratches down his back. He beat their five-year-old daughter Jodi and Joy’s father, Clyde “Eddie” Bedford, who used a wheelchair. Then he set the house on fire. Investigators found the blaze had been started in three separate places and established that all three victims were dead before the flames spread.

Hummel drove to California. Border officers stopped him at the San Diego crossing on December 20, as he returned on foot from Mexico, and he confessed to Texas investigators two days later. A Tarrant County jury convicted him of capital murder on June 23, 2011, and he was sentenced to death. A March 2020 execution date was stayed because of the pandemic. Texas executed him by lethal injection on June 30, 2021.

From the book

Read the full story

This case is told in full in True Crime Case Histories, Volume 22 by Jason Neal.

Get Volume 22 on Amazon

Case photographs

2 photos
John Hummel
John Hummel
John Hummel
John Hummel

Where it happened

Kennedale, TX
Kennedale, Texas, where the Hummel family was killed in 2009 · Open in Google Maps

Why this case

“Hummel’s rat poison attempt is the detail I keep turning over. It failed, the family assumed the food had spoiled, and life went on for another two months. Cases like this often have a rehearsal buried somewhere in them, and it almost never registers as one until afterward.”

Jason Neal, author of True Crime Case Histories

More from Volume 22

12 chapters
Mark Dean Schwab: The Kite Flyer

The Kite Flyer

Chapter 1 · Mark Dean Schwab

Mark Dean Schwab groomed and murdered 11-year-old Junny Rios-Martinez Jr. in Brevard County, Florida, in 1991. Executed 2008. Case photos.

The Killing Cousins: The Killing Cousins

The Killing Cousins

Chapter 2 · The Killing Cousins

David Alan Gore and Fred Waterfield killed six women and girls around Vero Beach, Florida, from 1981 to 1983. Photos from the Killing Cousins case.

Norma Leanues: Room 214

Room 214

Chapter 3 · Norma Leanues

Nurse Anne Capute was acquitted in 1981 of murdering cancer patient Norma Leanues at Morton Hospital in Taunton, Massachusetts. Case photos.

John List: The Vanishing Act

The Vanishing Act

Chapter 4 · John List

John List killed his wife, mother and three children in Westfield, New Jersey, in 1971, then vanished for 18 years. Photos from the List case.

The Bever Family Murders: The Broken Arrow Massacre

The Broken Arrow Massacre

Chapter 5 · The Bever Family Murders

Robert and Michael Bever stabbed five of their own family to death in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, in 2015. Photos from the Bever family murders.

Kosta Fotopoulos: The Boardwalk Murders

The Boardwalk Murders

Chapter 6 · Kosta Fotopoulos

Kosta Fotopoulos and Deidre Hunt killed two men in Daytona Beach in 1989 in a plot to murder his wife Lisa. Photos from the boardwalk murders case.

Vera Jo Reigle: Goodnight, Sugar Babe

Goodnight, Sugar Babe

Chapter 7 · Vera Jo Reigle

Vera Jo Reigle, a disabled young mother, was stabbed on a railroad trestle in Findlay, Ohio, in 2011 by two housemates. Photos from the case.

Guy Rasmussen: The Lakewood Monster

The Lakewood Monster

Chapter 9 · Guy Rasmussen

Nine-year-old Cindy Allinger vanished in Lakewood, Washington, on July 4, 1996. Guy Rasmussen was convicted of her murder in 1999. Case photos.

Debora Green: Over Our Dead Bodies

Over Our Dead Bodies

Chapter 10 · Debora Green

Physician Debora Green set the 1995 fire that killed her children Tim and Kelly in Prairie Village, Kansas, and poisoned her husband. Case photos.

Mark Hacking: The Perfect Lie

The Perfect Lie

Chapter 11 · Mark Hacking

Mark Hacking reported his wife Lori missing after a Salt Lake City jog in July 2004. He had shot her and lied to her for years. Photos from the case.

John Norman Collins: The All-American Monster

The All-American Monster

Chapter 12 · John Norman Collins

John Norman Collins was convicted in 1970 of killing Karen Sue Beineman, one of seven young women who died near Ypsilanti, Michigan. Case photos.

About the author

Jason Neal writes the True Crime Case Histories series, which has covered hundreds of real cases from the United States and around the world since 2019. Each volume collects twelve cases, researched from court records, police reports and news coverage. jasonneal.com

Read it in Volume 22 next chapterGuy Rasmussen