Volume 5
Melissa Ann Shepard: The Black Widow

Volume 5 · Chapter 9

The Black Widow

Melissa Ann Shepard

Victims: Gordon Stewart · Robert Friedrich · Alex Strategos · Fred Weeks

Nova Scotia, Canada, and Pinellas County, Florida 1 photo

Case at a glance

When
1991–2012
Where
Nova Scotia, Canada, and Pinellas County, Florida
Perpetrator
Melissa Ann Shepard (also known as Melissa Stewart and Melissa Friedrich)
Victims
Gordon Stewart, Robert Friedrich, Alex Strategos, Fred Weeks
Outcome
Convicted of manslaughter in 1992, of grand theft and forgery in Florida in 2005, and of administering a noxious substance in 2013; released in 2016 under a peace bond

The case

Melissa Ann Shepard was born in New Brunswick in 1935. For decades she targeted lonely older men, often widowers met through church circles or online, and used several married names.

In April 1991 her husband, Gordon Stewart, died near Halifax, Nova Scotia, after she ran over him with a car; tests found tranquilizers in his system. She was convicted of manslaughter in 1992 and sentenced to six years but was released after about two. Her next husband, Robert Friedrich, died in the early 2000s after a steep decline in health. His sons blamed her, but she was never charged. In Florida she took money from Alex Strategos, a man she met online, and in 2005 she was sentenced to five years for grand theft and forgery.

In September 2012, at 77, she married Fred Weeks, a widower in his late seventies, in Nova Scotia. He became seriously ill on their honeymoon trip to Newfoundland and survived, and she was charged with attempted murder. In 2013 she pleaded guilty to the lesser charges of administering a noxious substance and failing to provide the necessaries of life and was sentenced to three and a half years. Released in March 2016 under a peace bond that barred her from using the internet, she was arrested the next month for allegedly using a computer at a Halifax library. Prosecutors withdrew those charges in December 2016.

From the book

Read the full story

This case is told in full in True Crime Case Histories, Volume 5 by Jason Neal.

Get Volume 5 on Amazon

Case photographs

1 photo
The many faces of Melissa Ann Shepard
The many faces of Melissa Ann Shepard

Where it happened

Halifax, NS
Halifax, near where Gordon Stewart died in 1991 · Open in Google Maps

Why this case

“People tend to picture a predator as young and strong. Shepard was in her late seventies when she drugged Fred Weeks, and that image worked in her favor for years. The pattern was there in court records long before 2012, which is why I think her story is worth knowing for anyone with an aging parent who dates online.”

Jason Neal, author of True Crime Case Histories

More from Volume 5

12 chapters
Larry and Carri Williams: The Homeschoolers

The Homeschoolers

Chapter 1 · Larry and Carri Williams

Larry and Carri Williams of Sedro-Woolley, Washington, were convicted in the 2011 death of their adopted daughter Hana Williams. Case photos.

Peter Madsen: The Submarine Case

The Submarine Case

Chapter 2 · Peter Madsen

Danish inventor Peter Madsen murdered Swedish journalist Kim Wall aboard his homemade submarine near Copenhagen in August 2017. Case photos.

Louis Perez: Unlucky 13

Unlucky 13

Chapter 3 · Louis Perez

Marine Sgt. Louis Perez, Dorothy Maraglino, and Jessica Lopez were convicted of the 2012 Fallbrook, California, murder of Brittany Killgore. Case photos.

William Cosden: Divine Justice

Divine Justice

Chapter 4 · William Cosden

William Cosden Jr. was convicted in 2002 of the 1973 murder of 14-year-old Kathy Devine near Olympia, Washington, after a DNA match. Case photos.

Ed Gingerich: The Amish Killer

The Amish Killer

Chapter 5 · Ed Gingerich

Amish farmer Ed Gingerich killed his wife Katie in Rockdale Township, Pennsylvania, in 1993 and was found guilty but mentally ill. Case photos.

John Famalaro: Cold Storage Killer

Cold Storage Killer

Chapter 6 · John Famalaro

John Famalaro was sentenced to death for the 1991 murder of Denise Huber, whose body was found in a freezer in Arizona in 1994. Case photos.

Sally Challen: Coercive Control

Coercive Control

Chapter 7 · Sally Challen

Sally Challen killed her husband Richard in Claygate, Surrey, in 2010. Her murder conviction was quashed in 2019; she admitted manslaughter. Case photos.

Jack Spillman: The Werewolf Butcher

The Werewolf Butcher

Chapter 8 · Jack Spillman

Jack Owen Spillman III killed Penny Davis near Tonasket and Rita and Mandy Huffman in East Wenatchee, Washington, in 1994–95. Case photos.

Brett Ryan: The Crossbow Killer

The Crossbow Killer

Chapter 10 · Brett Ryan

Brett Ryan killed his mother Susan and brothers Chris and A.J. with a crossbow in Scarborough, Toronto, in August 2016. Photos from the Ryan case.

Gerald Robinson: Murder in the Sacristy

Murder in the Sacristy

Chapter 11 · Gerald Robinson

Father Gerald Robinson killed Sister Margaret Ann Pahl at Mercy Hospital in Toledo, Ohio, in 1980 and was convicted in 2006. Case photos.

Dixie Dyson: Devious Dixie

Devious Dixie

Chapter 12 · Dixie Dyson

Dixie Dyson arranged the 1984 murder of her partner Mel Dyson in Huntington Harbour, Huntington Beach, California, with two hired men. Case photos.

About the author

Jason Neal writes the True Crime Case Histories series, which has covered hundreds of real cases from the United States and around the world since 2019. Each volume collects twelve cases, researched from court records, police reports and news coverage. jasonneal.com

Read it in Volume 5 next chapterBrett Ryan