Volume 23
Ronald Gene Simmons: Mockingbird Hill

Volume 23 · Chapter 5

Mockingbird Hill

Ronald Gene Simmons

Victims: Becky Simmons · Sheila McNulty · Kathy Kendrick · Jim Chaffin

Mockingbird Hill near Dover, and Russellville, Pope County, Arkansas 5 photos

Case at a glance

When
December 22–28, 1987
Where
Mockingbird Hill near Dover, and Russellville, Pope County, Arkansas
Perpetrator
Ronald Gene Simmons Sr.
Victims
Becky Simmons, Sheila McNulty, Kathy Kendrick, Jim Chaffin
Outcome
Convicted of capital murder in 1988 and again in 1989 and sentenced to death both times; executed by lethal injection on June 25, 1990

The case

Ronald Gene Simmons was a retired Air Force sergeant who bought a wooded tract north of Dover, Arkansas, in 1983 and called it Mockingbird Hill. There was no telephone and no running water, and a block wall along the road kept the place out of sight. In November 1987 he had his younger children dig a pit about four feet deep, telling them it was for another outhouse.

Between December 22 and December 26, 1987, Simmons killed fourteen of his own relatives there: his wife Becky, the four school-age children still at home, his grown children and their spouses, and his grandchildren. He shot every adult and strangled every child, and seven bodies went into the pit. On December 28 he drove into Russellville and went to four businesses across the town, shooting six people. Kathy Kendrick, twenty-four, who had rejected his attentions at a freight company and reported them, and James Chaffin, thirty-three, a firefighter who was simply in the way, both died.

Simmons surrendered at the last stop and did not fight the case. A Franklin County jury convicted him of the Russellville murders in May 1988, and a Johnson County jury convicted him of the fourteen family killings in February 1989. He waived his appeals. He was executed by lethal injection on June 25, 1990, the first Arkansas prisoner put to death by that method.

From the book

Read the full story

This case is told in full in True Crime Case Histories, Volume 23 by Jason Neal.

Get Volume 23 on Amazon

Case photographs

5 photos
Ronald Gene Simmons
Ronald Gene Simmons
Mockingbird Hil
Mockingbird Hil
Ronald Gene Simmons and family
Ronald Gene Simmons and family
Ronald Gene Simmons
Ronald Gene Simmons
Ronald Gene Simmons
Ronald Gene Simmons

Where it happened

Dover, Arkansas
Near Dover, the site of the Mockingbird Hill property · Open in Google Maps

Why this case

“Writing this one, I kept running into the same wall: almost nobody outside that fence knew anything. Neighbors saw a gate and a man who kept to himself. His children saw the rest of it and had no way to reach help. I gave the sixteen people he killed more space than I gave him.”

Jason Neal, author of True Crime Case Histories

More from Volume 23

12 chapters
Susan Wright: Divorce by Homicide

Divorce by Homicide

Chapter 1 · Susan Wright

Susan Wright stabbed her husband Jeff 193 times and buried him in the backyard of their Harris County, Texas, home in 2003. Case photos.

Tony Costa: Keep Digging

Keep Digging

Chapter 2 · Tony Costa

Tony Costa killed Patricia Walsh and Mary Anne Wysocki after they visited Provincetown in January 1969. Four bodies were found in Truro. Case photos.

Johnny Lee Thornton: Bad John

Bad John

Chapter 3 · Johnny Lee Thornton

Military policeman Johnny Lee Thornton killed three teenagers at Fort Leonard Wood, Missouri, in January 1977. One girl walked out. Case photos.

Brittany Norwood: The Closing Shift

The Closing Shift

Chapter 4 · Brittany Norwood

Brittany Norwood murdered coworker Jayna Murray at the Bethesda, Maryland, Lululemon store in March 2011 and staged a break-in. Case photos.

The Lonely Hearts Killers: The Lonely Hearts Killers

The Lonely Hearts Killers

Chapter 6 · The Lonely Hearts Killers

Raymond Fernandez and Martha Beck robbed and killed widows across 1940s America. Janet Fay died at Valley Stream, New York, in 1949. Case photos.

The Speed Freak Killers: The Speed Freaks

The Speed Freaks

Chapter 7 · The Speed Freak Killers

Wesley Shermantine and Loren Herzog killed across San Joaquin County, California, from 1984 to 1998. Photos from the Speed Freak Killers case.

Scott White: Two Hundred Feet Below

Two Hundred Feet Below

Chapter 8 · Scott White

Scott Johnson died below the cliffs at Manly, Sydney, in 1988. Scott White admitted the killing decades later. Photos from the Scott Johnson case.

The Bitter Blood Murders: Fourteen Days

Fourteen Days

Chapter 9 · The Bitter Blood Murders

Fritz Klenner and Susie Newsom Lynch killed seven relatives in North Carolina and Kentucky in 1984 and 1985. Photos from the Bitter Blood case.

Mark Redwine: Middle Mountain

Middle Mountain

Chapter 10 · Mark Redwine

Dylan Redwine, 13, vanished during a court-ordered 2012 visit near Vallecito, Colorado. His father Mark was convicted in 2021. Case photos.

Stephen Gore: The Body Broker

The Body Broker

Chapter 11 · Stephen Gore

Stephen Gore’s Biological Resource Center in Phoenix cut up donated bodies and sold the parts until an FBI raid in 2014. Photos from the case.

Betty Lou Beets: The Wishing Well

The Wishing Well

Chapter 12 · Betty Lou Beets

Betty Lou Beets buried two husbands in the yard of her Cedar Creek Lake home in Texas. She was executed in 2000. Photos from the Beets case.

About the author

Jason Neal writes the True Crime Case Histories series, which has covered hundreds of real cases from the United States and around the world since 2019. Each volume collects twelve cases, researched from court records, police reports and news coverage. jasonneal.com

Read it in Volume 23 next chapterThe Lonely Hearts Killers