Volume 3
Marjorie Orbin: Arizona Torso Murder #2

Volume 3 · Chapter 9

Arizona Torso Murder #2

Marjorie Orbin

Victim: Jay Orbin

Phoenix, Arizona 11 photos

Case at a glance

When
September 2004
Where
Phoenix, Arizona
Perpetrator
Marjorie Ann Orbin
Victim
Jay Orbin
Outcome
Convicted of first-degree murder in 2009 and sentenced to life without parole; convictions affirmed on appeal in 2011

The case

Marjorie Orbin was a former Las Vegas showgirl. She and Jay Orbin, who ran Jayhawk International, a Native American art business in Phoenix, divorced in 1998 but went on living together as husband and wife while raising their young son. Jay was last heard from on September 8, 2004, his 45th birthday, when he phoned his mother. Marjorie told people he had left on another business trip.

On October 23, 2004, a transient found a large plastic storage tub wrapped in black trash bags in the desert near Tatum and Dynamite boulevards in north Phoenix. Inside was a man’s torso, later identified as Jay. Detectives learned that Marjorie had used his credit card to buy black trash bags and two 50-gallon containers, one of them identical to the tub down to its color and UPC code. They also found she had been draining his money and seeing another man, Larry Weisberg. She was arrested on December 6, 2004.

After an eight-month trial, a Maricopa County jury convicted Marjorie in 2009 of first-degree murder, along with theft and fraud counts. On October 1, 2009, she was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. The Arizona Court of Appeals affirmed her convictions in November 2011. She has blamed Weisberg, a claim the jury did not accept.

From the book

Read the full story

This case is told in full in True Crime Case Histories, Volume 3 by Jason Neal.

Get Volume 3 on Amazon

Case photographs

11 photos
Marjorie Orbin
Marjorie Orbin
Marjorie Orbin
Marjorie Orbin
Marjorie Orbin
Marjorie Orbin
Marjorie Orbin
Marjorie Orbin
Rubbermaid container with Torso of Jay Orbin
Rubbermaid container with Torso of Jay Orbin
Marjorie, Jay & Son
Marjorie, Jay & Son
Marjorie Orbin
Marjorie Orbin
Marjorie Orbin
Marjorie Orbin
Jay Orbin
Jay Orbin
Jay Orbin & Son
Jay Orbin & Son
Marjorie Orbin
Marjorie Orbin

Where it happened

North Phoenix, AZ
North Phoenix desert, where Jay Orbin’s remains were found · Open in Google Maps

Why this case

“The detail that settled this case was a plastic tub. Marjorie Orbin spent weeks telling everyone Jay was on the road, while a store receipt and a UPC code told a different story. I want readers to notice how often ordinary purchases, not dramatic confessions, are what finally solve a murder.”

Jason Neal, author of True Crime Case Histories

More from Volume 3

12 chapters
Jessica Wongso: The Coffee Killer

The Coffee Killer

Chapter 1 · Jessica Wongso

Jessica Wongso was convicted of killing her friend Mirna Salihin with cyanide-laced iced coffee at a Jakarta café in January 2016. Case photos.

Kenneth Regan: Captain Cash

Captain Cash

Chapter 2 · Kenneth Regan

Kenneth Regan and William Horncy murdered Amarjit Chohan and four family members in 2003 to take over his Heathrow freight firm. Case photos.

John Tanner: The Oxford Murder

The Oxford Murder

Chapter 3 · John Tanner

John Tanner strangled his girlfriend Rachel McLean, an Oxford student, in 1991, then appealed for help finding her on television. Case photos.

Larry Gene Bell: God Chose Us

God Chose Us

Chapter 4 · Larry Gene Bell

Larry Gene Bell abducted and killed Shari Faye Smith and Debra May Helmick in South Carolina in 1985, then called the Smith family. Case photos.

Steven Capobianco: A Unicorn Among Beasts

A Unicorn Among Beasts

Chapter 5 · Steven Capobianco

Steven Capobianco was convicted of killing his pregnant former girlfriend, Carly “Charli” Scott, on Maui, Hawaii, in 2014. Photos from the case.

John Sweeney: The Canal Killer

The Canal Killer

Chapter 6 · John Sweeney

John Sweeney, the Canal Killer, murdered Paula Fields in London and Melissa Halstead in the Netherlands and was convicted in 2011. Case photos.

Mihaly Illes: The Head in the Bucket

The Head in the Bucket

Chapter 7 · Mihaly Illes

Mihaly Illes shot Javan Dowling in a van in Vancouver in April 2001, then kept his head in a bucket before it was buried near Squamish. Case photos.

Valerie Pape: Arizona Torso Murder #1

Arizona Torso Murder #1

Chapter 8 · Valerie Pape

Valerie Pape killed her husband, Ira Pomerantz, in Scottsdale, Arizona, in January 2000 and was seen dumping his torso in a Mesa dumpster. Case photos.

Michella Welch and Jennifer Bastian: The Tacoma Murders

The Tacoma Murders

Chapter 10 · Michella Welch and Jennifer Bastian

Michella Welch and Jennifer Bastian were murdered in Tacoma, Washington, in 1986; DNA later showed two different killers. Photos from the Tacoma cases.

Jordan Graham: The Killer Bride

The Killer Bride

Chapter 11 · Jordan Graham

Jordan Linn Graham pushed her husband of eight days, Cody Johnson, off a cliff in Glacier National Park, Montana, in July 2013. Case photos.

Neville Heath: The Lady Killer

The Lady Killer

Chapter 12 · Neville Heath

Neville Heath murdered Margery Gardner in Notting Hill, London, and Doreen Marshall in Bournemouth in the summer of 1946. Photos from the Heath case.

About the author

Jason Neal writes the True Crime Case Histories series, which has covered hundreds of real cases from the United States and around the world since 2019. Each volume collects twelve cases, researched from court records, police reports and news coverage. jasonneal.com

Read it in Volume 3 next chapterMichella Welch and Jennifer Bastian